Too Good To Be True

[liquidtears]

Title: Too Good To Be True - Chapter One: Return Of Loved Ones
Auth: eternal_moonie
Rat: NC-17 / Adult
Sum: Alison finally returns with Dusty (who she slept with the night before) from Las Vegas to Oakdale again... Can she handle the return of her ex-boyfriend and her best friend?
Pairings: Alison/Aaron ; Alison/OC
Disclaimer: I don't own ATWT, just my madeup character.

 

Chapter 1: Return of Loved Ones
 
"Oh My God...." Emily Stewart whispered as she had seen who came inside Al's, her hand in front of her mouth. They both sat down at the booth where Emily was sitting. Aaron Snyder and Jan Sanders. Both friends of her baby sister, one had been her sister's boyfriend, the other was just a good friend. "Hey there, Emily." Jan said to Emily. Emily hugged both of them. "Jan! Aaron! It's so good to see you!" Emily told the two after their hug.

 

Alison stood in a bathroom under the shower in a hotel room in Las Vegas. Well, she more liked leaned against the wall, hands running through her blonde hair as she let tears fall out of her eyes while the shower rained down on her and her body. *What have I done? I slept with Dusty, who likes my sister, for God's sake! She so isn't going to forgive me when she finds out! Ohhh Aaron... I miss you... I wish you were here right now!* the youngest Stewart daughter thought.  

 

"Thank you, Emily. Have you seen your sister around?" Aaron asked as Jan had gone to order for them. Three cups of coffee and some breakfast. The booth wasn't so far from the counter, so Jan could hear every word they were saying. "She's not in Oakdale, but she's been here. She's out of town visiting some friends." Emily told Aaron. "Really? I'm surprised she even got back to Oakdale." Aaron said as Jan placed the three cups of coffee in front of them. "Our food will be there soon." Jan told them. "She always complained about Oakdale, was so happy to be out of this town." Aaron continued on telling Emily. Emily nodded. "Thanks Jan." Emily said as she took a sip from her coffee.

 

*I can't stay in this shower forever. I've been taking showers so many times a day now. But if Dusty hadn't been there...* Alison closed her eyes, she kept seeing what had happened flashing in front of her. The pocket knife she used to defend herself from Lance, to slice open his cheek... the blood that was on her bathrobe... on the floor. In fast response she turned around and turned the shower handles to stop the water flowing. She opened her eyes again and got out of the shower to dry herself off and wrap a towel around herself. *I was all wrong. Lance wasn't going to make me an actress. He was going to make another porn movie.* Alison thought as she left the bathroom and walked into the hotel room. As she looked at the empty bed, she remembered being in Dusty's arms and moving around, their lips kissing over and over. She turned her head in fear when there was a knock on the door. She didn't move. "Alison? It's me, Dusty. Open up." A sigh of relief escaped her lips as Alison moved to the door to open it. Dusty walked inside and immediately closed the door again.

 

Aaron, Emily & Jan had started on their breakfast. Everyone was making plans. Emily was worried sick about receiving no word from either Alison or Dusty, so she would call them later. Aaron was going to drive by the Snyder Farm to let the other family members know he was back and Jan was going to get used to his hotel room at the Lakeview. His luggage would be arriving there soon. "So Jan, would you like to come along to the Farm? You can see Holden, Jack, Lily, Brad and all the kids again?" Aaron asked his buddy from childhood.

"Maybe some other time, Aaron. My luggage will be arriving soon at the Lakeview, better to be there then absent when the luggage arrives." Jan told his friend. Aaron nodded. "Ah, I see. No worries, buddy, I can maybe give you a ride to the Lakeview on my motorcycle?" Aaron asked. Jan chuckled. "Two boys on a motorcycle? What will the people think, Aaron?" He asked with a grin.

 

Alison looked at Dusty. "You still have some blood on your shirt." Alison said. Dusty shrugged. "Don't worry about..." "No, I'm going to remove it for you." Alison said and grabbed a washcloth from the bathroom after sprinkling some water on it. She then dabbed the cloth on Dusty's shirt. It was gone in a matter of seconds.
"It's gone." Dusty said. "Yeah," Alison said with a smile, "It's cold water that's the secret." Alison said. Then she looked up and stared into Dusty's smoldering eyes. Dusty did the same, but didn't give into their feelings. No, they moved away from eachother. "Well, are you ready to leave Las Vegas and return to Oakdale?" Dusty asked her. "Yeah. Just let me get dressed and I'll be all set." Alison said as she grabbed her clothes and went into the bathroom to get changed.

 

"Well, it was nice seeing you again, Emily. We'll see you later okay? And can you keep in touch if you hear anything about Alison?" Aaron asked as he and Jan got up when they finished breakfast. "Sure thing." Emily said with a smile. "C'mon Jan." Aaron said and the two were gone on Aaron's motorcycle that stood outside.

Emily didn't even watch them leave as she pulled out her cellphone and called Dusty.

 

Dusty picked up right away. "Emily?" Dusty asked. "Where have you been? I have been waiting for news, so nervous when you would call, and when you didn't I decided to call instead. How is Ali?" Emily asked Dusty.

"She's fine, we're about to go to the airport actually." Dusty said to her, the exact moment when Alison got out of the bathroom, all dressed. Alison was wearing a dark blue shirt and blue jeans. "Can I talk to her?" Emily asked. Dusty looked at Alison who shook her head. "You can't. She's in the shower. But we're going to be home soon." Emily was relieved that they would be coming home soon. "Okay, thanks for everything, Dusty. I can't wait to have you both home safe. I love you." Emily said through her cellphone. Dusty nodded and told her he loved her as well. He broke the connection and put his cellphone back. "Ready to get out of here?" Dusty asked. Alison nodded as she zipped up her luggage bag. "Yeah." Alison said and opened the door and walked out with her backpack. Dusty made movement toward the door, but then turned around and looked at the unmade bed, memories of him and Alison clouding his vision. He then closed the door for good and walked with Alison downstairs to check out.

 

The motorcycle stopped in front of the Lakeview. "Thanks again, Aaron. And say hi to your family for me." Jan said as he gave Aaron their special handshake they had done as kids. "My pleasure and no problem, man." Aaron said as he drove off. *Let's check in with Daddy and see if he got any news.* Jan thought as he entered the Lakeview and went straight to the counter. He got the electronic card for his suite and went up the elevator to the correct floor with a bellboy who had his luggage. The elevator pinged and the doors opened. Jan and the bellboy walked to the suite and the bellboy waited until Jan had opened the door by slipping the electronic card through the slot. The bellboy put his luggage on the couch. "Thank you very much." Jan said and gave the bellboy a tip. "Thank you, Sir. Enjoy your stay at the Lakeview." The bellboy then left. "Oh, but I will..." Jan said as he began to put all his stuff from the luggage into drawers and other places, as thoughts about Alison consumed him. His last birthday party, for example...

 

~Hey birthday boy, check this out! When we saw this in the store, we just KNEW you had to get it for your birthday! Jan took the package and opened it. It was a porn video. "Gee, thanks guys!" Jan had said to them. "You're welcome, buddy!" Jason said and grinned. "What's that grin for?" Jan asked. "Oh you know, don't you want to display your merchandise after you bought it?" Bart asked. Jan shrugged. "Yeah, I guess." Jan said and went over to his dvd player on his flatscreen and inserted the disc. He then pressed another button and the disc cover slid closed. Jan changed from tv to dvd and the scene started up.... Jan dropped the remote and stared at the screen. There was the one girl he always carried a photograph of in his wallet! Alison Stewart with a lollipop in her mouth!! She then stripped her clothes off and a man appeared. She took his member in her mouth like it was nothing... "Okay, everyone, that's it for tonight, the party's over!" Jan said, pressing stop after he had scooped the DVD remote from the floor again and changed it to tv again. "DUDE! What are you doing? It was just getting good!" His friends called out. "No, it wasn't. Please, just get out of here!" Jan ordered them. "Whatever." They said and left. Jan then started cleaning everything, while thoughts clouded his better judgment. ALISON STEWART made a porno?! Was she on drugs?! He grabbed his cellphone and called Alison... but another woman picked up, not knowing about Alison Stewart. Jan apologized and wished her a goodnight. When Jan was done, he pulled the dvd out and placed it back in the package. He walked with the dvd to his bedroom, where he undressed to his briefs and sat down on the edge of his bed, staring at his flatscreen in his bedroom and the dvd. Looks changed from the flatscreen to the new dvd... and then he picked up the remote and turned on the flatscreen. His fingers opened the dvd package and took out the dvd and placed it in the dvd player, closed it and pressed play. He watched, transfixed.

 

Jan Sanders watched how the one he loved was taken, how she moaned out that it felt so good, when he pulled his cock out from his briefs and began to jerk off, while tears fell from his eyes, not believing he had gotten under the spell of this porno.... of Alison Stewart the pornstar...

 

Jan still had teary eyes while the memory washed over him. The moment after he was done, did his cellphone ring. He picked up as he saw that there was no caller ID. He had been waiting for that call. "Jan here, I'm in position at the Lakeview." Jan told the other person at the end of the line. "You make me so proud, son." James Stenbeck said on the other end of the line. "Thank you, Father. Now, any news about Alison from your spies?" On the other end far away, a ring of cigar smoke was blown out. "Ohhh, you'll be very happy, my son. I happen to know she will be coming home from Las Vegas really soon..."

 

End of Chapter One: Return of Loved Ones

 

Chapter Two: Welcome Home, Alison

 

"That is amazing news, Daddy.'' Jan said with a grin to his dad. ''Have you already mingled with the rest of the lovely folk of Oakdale, Son?'' James asked. ''Emily Stewart... and Aaron Snyder is back too.'' Jan said, with venom in his voice that he had originally never had for his childhood friend. ''I trust you've made the necessary arrangements that I've taught you?'' James asked his son. ''Of course, Father. She will be arriving soon.'' Jan said. ''As a matter of fact, Aaron invited me to the barn to see the other Snyders.'' James laughed. ''You should so worm your way back into their lives. Don't you worry, everything will work out.'' James told his son.

''Goodbye Father. I'll let you know how things go.'' And with that Jan disconnected the call.

 

The moment he slipped his phone back into his pocket, he went back to the trip down memory lane...

 

~Right after cumming, having shouted his release in a strangled cry, he got up from the bed, made his way over to the dvd player fully nude, and yanked the dvd disc out of the dvd player. Jan placed it back in the package and then went over to the tool drawer. He pulled out a hammer and began to pounce on the disc, screaming until the dvd was destroyed. Never again would he want to see that dvd again. *Ali... I love you...* Jan thought as he finally went to sleep... but sleep would not come.

 

Instead, a version of the porn movie invaded his dreams, but then it wasn't the guy who was doing Alison, it was Jan Sanders himself. Even Alison herself knew it wasn't the guy. She was riding him hard, going up and down his hard cock. ''Jan!! Ahhh yes, take me hard!! I need you, want you to cum in my pussy!" With animalistic pleasure, Jan pushed his mouth on her breasts as he fucked her. ''JAN! I'm so close.... cum with me baby!'' Alison moaned out.

 

Jan opened his eyes and shuddered with release. ''Never again... please, never again.'' He whispered to himself, as he tried to go back to sleep again. Which worked this time.~

 

Once again he remembered with tears in his eyes. ''Yeah, Aaron. Maybe it IS a good idea to visit your Farm." Jan said with a grin and then left his suite and walked down the hall to the elevator. He kept his electronic keycard in his pocket. He left the Lakeview and started to walk to the Snyder Farm. Again his cellphone ringed. He checked caller ID and smiled when he accepted the call. "Hey there, beautiful. You're at the Airport? And you've seen her with Dusty? Excellent news. Well, you know where to go, I will meet you there. Love you too.'' Jan said and broke the connection, another grin on his face. *You so can't resist her, Aaron.* Jan thought as he continued on.

 

Meanwhile, Aaron had just parked his motorcycle at the Snyder Farm, checked his messages again and still had no update from Emily. He missed Alison very much. Aaron walked inside the Snyder house and found Luke there. "Aaron, you're back!'' Luke said with a grin on his face and gave him a handshake. *Would he know I'm gay? Of course not.* Luke thought as he zoned out for a bit. ''Yeah, I just came back. Hey, is Holden or anyone else here?'' Aaron asked. Lily appeared through the door. ''Luke, is that.... AARON!" Lily said and hugged him and kissed him on his cheek. ''It's so good to see you again!'' ''Aunt Lily, how have you been? It is good to see you again as well!'' Aaron said to Lily.

 

''When did you get back?'' Lily asked. ''Oh, just a couple of minutes ago." said a voice from behind the doorway. "Jan! So you did come!" Aaron said with a grin as he had turned his back to look who it was. Jan walked into the household and hugged Lily and kissed her softly on her cheek. ''Hey Luke." Jan said to him as he shook his hand. *My God, he is soo hot!* Luke thought, but... *Aaron's friend? No, pull up that wall buddy.* Luke thought. ''Yeah... we just got back actually. We met eachother again at Al's with Emily, and we had breakfast with her. Guess we were both looking forward to see Alison.'' Jan explained to Lily and Luke, when Meg Snyder walked down. ''Hey Aaron! How have you been?" She asked as she hugged him. "Hey, Aunt Meg. This is Jan Sanders, an old friend of mine." Aaron explained to Meg. ''Any friend of Aaron's is a friend of mine.'' Meg said to Jan who shook her hand.

 

''Aha! There you are!'' A blonde girl said as she came inside the house. ''Who are you?'' Aaron asked. The girl grinned.

 

Alison and Dusty just left the airport and stepped into a cab to go to Al's Diner. Alison was quiet on the way. Dusty called Emily to let her know they were going to Al's. Again Alison didn't want to talk to her sister. What was the point? She was going to see her again in a couple of minutes! ''ALISON!'' Emily said as she ran toward her sister to hug her. ''I am so happy to see that you're safe and sound!'' Emily said as she wrapped her arms around her sister. ''I am happy to be back too. I'm so sorry for all the things that I said!'' Alison said, sobbing in her sister's arms. ''Let's get you some coffee.'' Emily said and looked at Dusty. ''Right away.'' Dusty said with a grin. Emily pulled out a handkerchief for her sister to dab her eyes with. ''So it seems you're not the only one that has returned.'' Emily told her baby sister. Alison stopped in mid-wipe. ''What do you mean?'' Alison asked her sister. Emily grinned. ''Well, Aaron Snyder and Jan Sanders have both returned!'' Alison's eyes got huge. ''Oh my god...''

 

The girl grinned and walked toward the group. Then she threw her hands around Jan and kissed him hard on his lips. Jan kissed her back, also on her lips. ''Yep, Sadie, you found me. Sorry guys, this is my girlfriend Sadie Harrison. Sadie, this is Lily, Luke, Meg and Aaron Snyder." Sadie grinned. "Nice to meet all of you." Sadie said and her eyes lingered on Aaron. *So THIS is Aaron Snyder!* she thought. "Wow... uhm, you never said you had a girlfriend, Jan." Aaron said to him. "Yeah, I totally forgot to mention that." Jan said as he kissed Sadie again on her cheek this time...

 

End of Chapter Two: Welcome Home Alison

Chapter Three: Happy Reunion For One

 

Just that moment, Jan got a text message. ''Is it about her?'' Sadie whispered in Jan's ear. ''Yeah.'' Jan whispered back as he read the message and closed his cellphone. It was Emily who texted Jan to tell him that Alison was back and had added that Jan tell it to Aaron as well. She was going to stay at the Lakeview with Dusty and Emily. ''Who was that, Jan? Was that Emily?" Aaron asked him. Jan shook his head. ''It was my mom, she asked me if I had a good flight back to Oakdale. I just remembered to buy some stuff for dinner. Could Sadie stay here for a bit? I'll pick her up later. You could show her the horses at the stables?'' Jan suggested. ''You like horseriding? Oh My God, Jan and I love riding horses!'' Sadie said excitedly. *In more ways than one.* Sadie thought. Aaron was disappointed; it showed on his face. ''Yeah, sure, I guess." Aaron said as he tried to smile at Sadie. ''It was great to meet you all again. We will see lots more of eachother soon.'' Jan said and said his goodbyes to the rest of the Snyder family.

 

When he left the farm, he started running back to the Lakeview. He arrived there and went up the elevator to his suite. Once there, he took a nice shower. He put on some cologne and felt truly refreshed...

 

''So, what do you say we go back to the Lakeview, back to our room?" Emily asked her baby sister and Dusty after a healthy lunch. Well, she already had breakfast with Aaron and Jan, so had declined anything her boyfriend had thrown her her way. During the whole lunch, Alison couldn't stop asking about Jan and Aaron. A part of her was scared what would happen if they met; would she tell about her Crystal Meth addiction and her porn star career? ''I suggest we let Alison decide. Aaron is at the Snyders, Jan is somewhere at the Lakeview.'' Dusty spoke up as he looked at Alison. "Where do you want to go to first?'' Alison was asked. ''Can we go to the Lakeview first? I haven't seen him in so long, as for Aaron... well, true, it has been awhile, but not as long as it has been with Jan." Alison said to the two of them, her eyes hopeful. ''Sure, honey, let's go there.'' Emily said as she took Alison's bag and together the three went to the Lakeview.

 

''Aaron! This horse is so cute!'' Sadie said, caressing its mane. The horse whinnied softly. ''Seems like she likes you already. You sure have a way with horses, Sadie.'' Sadie turned to look at Aaron and grinned. ''Thanks, Aaron." "So... I had breakfast with Jan and a sister of a friend of mine... and Jan didn't mention you. Why do you think he didn't mention you?" Aaron asked Sadie. Sadie shrugged. ''I don't know...'' she said innocently. ''Hey, do you fancy a ride with me?'' Sadie asked. Aaron grinned. ''Sure.''

 

Alison, Dusty and Emily arrived at the Lakeview. During the ride, Alison could only think of her friends... well, her friend and her ex-boyfriend. She never looked at Dusty in the front mirror anymore. All she could think of was how fast she could meet them again. They went inside and Alison walked straight to the front desk. ''Can you tell me which room Jan Sanders is in?'' She asked the clerk. ''Uhm, I'm sorry, but we don't give out that sort of information about our guests.'' he told Alison. Her face fell. ''Oh.'' She said softly. She wasn't going to go all seductive on him, not anymore. She wasn't like that anymore. ''But I have a strong feeling you will see him soon. It's not like Oakdale's a big town anyway. You're bound to cross paths sooner or later.'' He said as he smiled at her. ''Miss Stewart, oh... I'm sorry, then you must be Alison. Enjoy your stay.'' He said and gave her the keycard for their room as he saw Emily and Dusty. ''It's okay.'' Emily said. Then they went to the elevator to go up to their floor. The elevator pinged just as someone left their suite for the second time that day. He turned around and Alison saw him. ''JAN!'' Alison exclaimed and ran toward him, her arms around his body instantly. ''ALISON!'' Jan exclaimed as he hugged her. She kissed him, but didn't mean to kiss him on his lips. ''I'm so glad you're back!'' Alison whispered against him. ''Me too, Ali. Me too.''

 

End of Chapter Three : Happy Reunion For One